When I tell people that I love D3 football, they look at me queerly. So then I go on one of my patented rants:
“Quick quiz: What was the best played college football game a year ago?”
They talk Alabama. They talk Texas. They talk USC.
I shake my head in dissent, dismissively.
“Whitewater and Mount Union. 1 penalty. Both teams executed brilliantly. It was easily the best game I watched all season. And it was in a title game that concluded this little thing called playoffs.”
Then I talk to them about Bethel and SJU’s epic battle in 2003, where more than 13,000 fans lined the stadium, braving freezing weather to watch the Johnnies come back in the final minutes to win 29-26, sealing coach Gagliardi’s record 409th victory, in a season in which SJU went out to easily outpoint Mount Union for the title. Or the fabled Miracle in the Mud, the playoff game between Central and Linfield, where a bad snap on a potential game-tying FG in OT was picked up by Central and run in for the game-winning score as overeager Linfield fans rushed the field, thinking the game was over.
Well, folks, the 2010 Tommie/Johnnie game ranks right up there with the best of them. In what was perhaps the most hyped D3 football game in Minnesota since at least Bethel/SJU in 2003, the game did what no one thought it could do: Live up to the hype.
You see, the Tommie/Johnnie rivalry goes way back. They kick St. John’s ass in basketball and baseball, but St. John’s owns football. In fact, the last time the Tommies beat the Johnnies in football Bill Clinton was getting intern love in the oval office – 1997. Twelve-straight Johnnie wins later and St. Thomas was starting to feel a lot like Bethel circa 1999.
You see, Tommie football has always been an enigma. In those 12 contests, I’d posit that at least half the time, St. Thomas actually had more talent on the field than St. John’s. What? Yeah, they’re always big with great athletes. Let’s face it, most football players like the bright lights and big city that is St. Thomas instead of the Nome-like isolation that exists at St. John’s. St. Thomas always had talent. They just never put it together into a cohesive unit.
But then Glenn Caruso showed up. And suddenly a talented Tommies team started to put it all together. In his first Tommie/Johnnie game, his squad scored what appeared to be the game-winning TD late in the game, only to have the referees rule them down at the 1. The next play, they fumbled, the Johnnies recovered and the Tommies were staring at a 12-9 home defeat. Then there was last year’s game which the Johnnies dominated for three quarters, only to have the Tommies score two late TDs after special teams miscues. In OT, the Johnnies scored a TD to win the game. But SJU had been served: the Tommies weren’t the patsies they’d been for the last decade.
And the football rivalry was renewed. Enter this year. The Tommies went deep in the playoffs last year, finishing 11-2, and returning all but two starters. The Johnnies were ranked high in the preseason, but lost a heartbreaker in OT to Wisconsin – Eau Claire in the second week of the season. Meaning a loss to the Tommies would essentially end all hope of a playoff berth. The Tommies were looking to get a monkey off their back. The Johnnies were playing for their lives.
And early on it showed. The Johnnies took the field in front of 16,421 fans, surely the most fans to watch a football game in Central Minnesota history. They looked loose, ready to go. And from the opening kickoff, they were, pounding out a 12 play drive that included runs by all four of their running backs (Schneider, Reding, Awe and Johnson) and a run by Boyle for good measure. 5 and a half minutes, 10 runs, and St. John’s was on top 7-0.
St. Thomas quickly responded, though, driving down the field before stalling at the SJU 10 yard line. They lined up for a chip shot FG, only to have their kicker shank it. Still 7-0 Johnnies. The Johnnies went back to their ball control offense, pounding out five more runs, before failing on a third and short. They punted away and again the Tommies move the ball easily, before Billy Lawrence picked off a Dakota Tracy pass at the 15.
Once again the Johnnies fable bend but don’t break defense was paying dividends. The pressure seemed to be causing the Tommies to crack. Maybe it was the overflow crowd or maybe it was the 12 year gorilla. Whatever it was, the Johnnies looked in total control of the game.
Yet, they only led 7-0. And after the interception they were unable to mount much of anything and again were forced to punt. And again the Tommies turned the ball over, this time on the odd off guard pitch play they run. And yet, again, the Johnnies failed to capitalize. After a 17-yard punt, the Tommies went two plays, capped by a 39-yard strike from Tracy to Margarit that tied the game at 7.
And it was on. The Tommies were staring at a -2 deficit in the turnover battle, but the scoreboard had ’em tied up. So the teams traded turnovers, Reding dropping the ball on a play that could have very easily been ruled incomplete, while the Tommies had their All-American center airmail a snap over QB Dakota Tracy’s head. The Johnnies recovered, yet were only able to net a FG and we went in at the half with a narrow 10-7 Johnnie lead.
And we were on to the second half, which soon turned into the Ben Wartman show. The Tommies star RB had been sidelined for most of the past two games with an injury. He practiced very little during the week. Yet, he showed up big time in the second half, finishing the day with 158 yards and three scores. The Johnnies had bottled him up in the past, accounting for two of the few games where he didn’t gain 100 yards in his career. But not today.
But let’s not get ahead of ourselves. The Tommies got very little on their first possession of the half, and the Johnnies began moving, driving as far as the Tommie 28, where they failed to convert on fourth and 1. It was a big miss, because it seemed to inflate the Tommies, who took the momentum and rolled down the field, running Wartman and Tracy, Tracy and Wartman, all the way for a score and their first lead of the afternoon. The Tommie faithful exploded. The Johnnies faithful sat nervously wondering if missed opportunities were going to end their playoff chances.
And that’s when senior QB Joe Boyle put the Johnnies on his shoulders and marched down the field, capping his exploits with two remarkably evasive runs, the first a 14 yarder, the second a 12 yard weave that resulted in a 17-14 Johnnie lead with about 13 minutes left.
And a couple plays later, it looked like the Johnnies were going to seal the deal. The Tommies got a little too cute on reverse play, with Dakota Tracy seemingly setting the ball on the ground for the Johnnies to recover. The Johnnies were in business at midfield. 50 yards away from getting back into the playoff race. 50 yards from yet another heart-rending loss for the Tommies.
They came oh-so-close, marching to the 15 yard line before stalling. Which brought on kicker Jimmie Mattson to bang a 32 yard FG and give the Johnnies a 20-14 lead.
But the Tommies weren’t quitting. In a back-and-forth slugfest, they stayed alive, converting a big third and two on a Tracy naked bootleg and an even bigger fourth and 4 on another Tracy bootleg. When the Johnnies face short yardage, they go option. Apparently the Tommies go bootleg. And it works. A couple Wartman runs later and they were in the endzone, a simple XP from taking the lead with 4 minutes left.
Only someone forgot to tell the kicker how easy extra points are. He missed. The score was tied and the Johnnies had the ball last. Or did they? Boyle made a couple huge plays with his arm and his legs and suddenly the Johnnies were at the St. Thomas 27 with about 50 seconds to play. Mattson has a huge leg, though accuracy is an issue, so I’m thinking 10 more yards and we’re going home with a last second FG win.
But then Boyle threw an ill-advised quick out to Harry Awe that was easily picked off. A couple plays later and for the second year in a row, the Tommie Johnnie game was headed to OT.
The Johnnies won the toss and chose to get the ball second. The Tommies had no problem marching the 25 OT yards and the extra point was an afterthought. 27-20 Tommies. Cue crazy Tommie fans and some sort of hammer and saw celebrating.
But the Johnnies, as they had all game, countered. A quick 11 yard gain on first down had them inside the 15. A dropped TD that had fans first celebrating and then questioning how you could drop such a beautiful throw and a couple runs later and they were staring at a 4th and 2. And Boyle again came through, this time avoiding a mad rush and hitting RB Stephen Johnson in the flat for a six yard score. Second OT, here we come!
But it was not to be. Just as Tommie fans were about to lament a 2OT loss that would be their 13th straight to the Johnnies, a bad hold meant kicker Jimmie Mattson plunked the ball off the left upright, the Tommie fans stormed the field and the Johnnie fans went home looking forward to next year.
It was a great game. As a fan of D3 football, that right there was why I love it. Both teams left everything they had on the field. Big plays abounded, heart-rending mishaps turned happiness into sorrow. And a D3 record 16,000+ fans exulted in the moment.
Twas definitely yet another D3 game for the ages.